Oxygen: The Most Overlooked Yield-Limiting Factor?
Share
By Curt Livesay
Over the course of the past year or so, I’ve become obsessed with one agronomic concept above all others. It’s the idea that the single most yield-limiting element for most farms is Oxygen. And yes, please note that I did NOT say yield-limiting “nutrient.”
From my perspective, the idea that we frequently hear referred to as “Liebig’s Law of the Minimum” (i.e., the idea that your yield is limited by something that you just need to add in the form of fertilizer) is mostly a great sales pitch.
And it’s also mostly BS.
In case you’ve never heard me present before, allow me to go ahead and lay out my biases here. I think that big fertilizer pushes that “Law of the Minimum” narrative because it sells more NPK. It strikes me as awfully convenient that you can just buy whatever nutrient you’re short on… so that you can then be short on something else instead. Oh, but don’t worry! They can sell you that, too.
Anywho, this isn’t supposed to be a hit piece on big fertilizer, so I’ll do my best to lock in here and re-focus.
Why Oxygen Availability Matters
Now, the skeptic must be thinking, “Hey, isn’t Oxygen the most abundant element in the Earth’s crust?” And if that’s you, you are correct. For what it’s worth, it’s also the second most abundant element in the atmosphere (behind Nitrogen) and the third most abundant in the universe (behind Hydrogen and Helium).
However, as it relates to raising crops, or really any plants for that matter, the mere existence of a lot of Oxygen out “there” in the Earth’s crust doesn’t mean anything if the plants can’t access it.
You see, from the soil surface up, plants need Carbon Dioxide to maximize productivity. (And if you want to go down a fun little rabbit hole sometime, go look up Elizabeth Ainsley’s research on the SoyFACE experiments at the University of Illinois. Long story short, increasing levels of CO2 to crops can have a pronounced and positive impact on their productivity.)
But from the soil surface down, plants need oxygen to maximize their productivity. And the major problem with that is that the Oxygen in the soil must compete with water for the exact same real estate.
What do I mean by that? It’s all about pore space.
Roots don’t grow “in” soil. They grow in the pore spaces in between soil particles. And all too often, that’s a limited amount of space.
So, when the rain comes, there are two issues that work in tandem to basically shortchange your crop roots’ access to oxygen in the soil.
Firstly, the water takes over that pore space. Secondly, the aerobic portion of the microbial community goes into full-on panic mode trying to survive, and it burns through whatever oxygen it can find.
The Timing of Waterlogging Is Critical
Now, I cannot emphasize enough here that the timing of when this happens is critical in terms of just how bad this can be for crops.
If you take nothing else away from this article, please burn this into your brain: the critical time to avoid waterlogging in your crops coincides with when that crop is determining the ultimate size of its “sink” (i.e., the grain or the bean, etc.).
So, while having water standing on your corn field any time after tassel isn’t ideal (research has shown that 3–6 days of standing water 10 days after tasseling can cut yield by up to almost 20%), it’s not nearly as devastating as those same 3–6 days of standing water occurring during V3–V6, when it will reduce the maximum yield potential by up to almost 40% according to the research.

For soybeans, the critical window to avoid waterlogging is pretty much the entire reproductive window, but most especially right at the transition from vegetative to reproductive growth (i.e., R1–R3). Waterlogging your soybeans at that time can cut your yield potential by almost 60%.

How Plants Respond to Stress
When you think about it, it makes a ton of sense that the worst time for your crop to be short on oxygen in the root zone is when it’s trying to figure out exactly how much effort to throw into reproduction.
So, let’s talk about this in human terms… think about a young couple looking to move across the country. They find a town that’s got low crime, inexpensive cost of living, good job markets, highly rated schools and hospitals, etc., etc.
They’re thinking, “What a great place to raise a family! Let’s go!”
Similarly, in a great environment with low stress and abundant oxygen to the roots, the plant is thinking, “Hey, this is a great place to raise a family! Let’s have more ‘kids’!”
But the opposite is also true.
Now let’s put that same young couple in a scenario where they’re being forced to move someplace because of one or both spouses’ jobs. The cost of the city they must go to is astronomical. Food is expensive. Housing is unaffordable anywhere that doesn’t have a terribly high crime rate. And for the sake of argument, the job they have feels unstable for whatever the reason.
Now that same couple is thinking, “Hey… let’s maybe hold off another year or two before having kids.”
Your plants are the EXACT same way. They’re trying to get a read on how conducive the environment is to successful reproduction.
The Impact of Soil Compaction
Another related issue that should very obviously come into play here as well is compaction.
University of MN research showed that a one-time 20-axle load on a wet clay loam was still causing compaction damage 12 years later. (For context here, a fully loaded 1,200-bushel grain cart is going to run 35–40 tons per axle.)
And the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) states that compaction can cut crop yields by as much as 60% in a worst-case scenario.
So obviously, that all sucks. But what can you do about it?
Managing Oxygen and Soil Structure
First and foremost, for any of those of you on the fence about whether you should spend the money to tile, please just do it. I think it’s probably the single best ROI you can get on any ground that’s even remotely heavy or tight.
Look, I understand why no-till is a thing. I spent several years on the board of the Pacific Northwest Direct Seed Association (it’s what they call no-till in the PNW).
I also want to go on the record here as saying that I hate recreational tillage, which happens far too often where I live in central IL.
I am obviously a huge proponent of environmental stewardship, and I think that building carbon and soil structure are two of the top priorities we need to have for building long-term healthy, sustainable soils; however, I also believe that the best way to do that may be with some short-term “losses” in order to reap some long-term “gains.”
More specifically, I think that sometimes (read: like once every 3–5 years), we may need to consider running an inline, straight-shank-style ripper, just to break through the compaction layer to get oxygen back down into the soil, and to give roots a chance to get back down there as well.
Other options I would recommend that are more situational in nature would be to apply BioCal from Midwestern BioAg (No, I don’t sell it, but I can put you in touch with the people who do), and, in some very specific situations, the Mole Plow is an option.
But definitely reach out to me directly to discuss it before you consider going that route.
Final Thoughts
Oh, and finally… speaking of water use and all that. Yes, I did use AI to generate the images here for me, but no, I did NOT use any AI in writing this article.
So take all of that for whatever it’s worth.
As always, feel free to reach out with your questions, comments, and smart remarks, and be sure to follow me on TikTok @AlchemyBioscience.